The Best Shrimp on the Planet: How Key West Pinks Get to Your Table
Posted by Greg Cain on Oct 24th 2026
If you have ever had a Key West Pink, you know. They are sweet, clean and tender, closer to lobster than to the shrimp most people grow up on. Ask people who cook a lot of shrimp which one they would pick, and you will hear this name more than any other.
So what makes them that good? And how do you get the very best of them on your own table, a thousand miles from Key West? We just spent time at the docks in Tampa where these boats unload, and here is what we learned.
It starts with where they live
Key West Pinks are wild. Nothing about them is farmed. They live over clean, sandy bottom under the clear blue water off the Florida Keys, some of the best shrimping grounds in the world. That water is what gives them their rosy shell and their sweet, clean flavor. You can taste the difference the first time you have them side by side with an ordinary shrimp.
They are caught at night
Pink shrimp are nocturnal. They bury in the sand during the day and come up to feed after dark, so that is when the boats fish. A captain and two or three mates drag their nets through the night, then pull in toward shore by morning to anchor and sleep. They stay out like that for 30 to 40 days at a time before coming home to unload.
The morning after our visit, at 9 AM, we pulled up a live ship-tracking map, and there they were, sitting at anchor just off Key West after a night's work.
Frozen within minutes, which beats "fresh"
This is the part that matters most on your plate. When a net comes up, the crew sorts the catch by hand on deck. Then the shrimp go straight into a super-chilled brine that freezes them almost instantly, and they stay in the freezer hold below deck for the rest of the trip.
That means a Key West Pink is frozen within minutes of leaving the water, at its absolute freshest, and it stays that way until you thaw it in your own kitchen. Shrimp sold as "fresh" at a seafood counter has often been frozen and thawed already, then left sitting in the case. Frozen at sea is as close to the boat as most of us will ever get.
Caught the right way
The best shrimp should also be shrimp you feel good about buying. Each net is led by a light "tickler" chain that skims just ahead of it, barely touching the sand. That is enough to startle the shrimp up into the net, which rides just above the sea floor instead of dragging across it. The nets carry turtle excluder devices that let sea turtles swim out unharmed, and escape panels that let fish slip out too.
Several boats in this fleet go a step further. They carry cameras as part of a two-year pilot program run by the Sustainable Fisheries Partnership and funded by the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation and Publix. The cameras watch the catch for the smalltooth sawfish, an endangered species that lives in these same South Florida waters, and any that turn up are released. In its first season the program logged more than 2,000 hours of trawling.
These are crews using technology to fish as safely and sustainably as they can.
Why we go to the docks ourselves
When you tell people you sell the best seafood in the country, you had better know the boats, the docks and the people behind it. So four of us from The Crab Place (me, Matt, Rebecca and Jess) went to Tampa to see it for ourselves.
Ernie, our buyer at the source, walked us through it while a boat unloaded right in front of us. Bag after bag came off the deck: red mesh sacks of frozen shrimp, about 70 pounds each. By the time they were done, that one boat had unloaded 1,150 bags, just over 80,000 pounds of shrimp, from a single trip.
Knowing the people at the source is how we get the best of the catch, and it is how we know exactly what we are sending you.
Checked three times before they reach you
Every load is inspected as it lands at the dock. Then it is checked again at the processing plant, where the heads come off and the shrimp are graded by size. When they reach us at The Crab Place, we check them one more time, so you get the finest Key West Pinks there are.
You do not have to go to Key West to get them
People sometimes assume the best Key West Pinks have to come from Key West. They do not. The shrimp are frozen solid the moment they leave the water, and the boats unload in Tampa. After that, what matters is who handles them and how they get to you.
Ours come to our facility in Maryland, where that last check happens. They ship to your door frozen, and from Maryland we reach the whole eastern third of the country by UPS Ground, which keeps shipping affordable. VIP members get UPS Ground shipping free.
Keep it simple when you cook them
Shrimp this good do not need much. Thaw them overnight in the fridge, or in a sealed bag under cold running water for about 20 minutes. Then cook them hot and fast: a few minutes in garlic butter, on the grill or under the broiler, just until they turn pink and curl into a loose C. A tight O means they went too long.
Two of our favorites to get you started:
15 minutes · Serves 4
Blackened Shrimp
Dip in melted butter, dredge in blackening seasoning, and sear in a hot cast-iron skillet for under a minute a side.
Get the recipe >
1½ hours · Serves 8
Seafood Paella
One big pan of saffron rice, chorizo and peppers, with the shrimp tucked in at the end so they stay tender.
Get the recipe >
The best shrimp on the planet are wild-caught off Key West, frozen at sea within minutes, and caught in a way that protects the grounds. We have been to the docks, we know the people, and we only buy the best. All you have to do is order them.
Wild-caught Key West Pink shrimp, frozen at sea and shipped to your door.
Shop Key West Pink ShrimpBy Greg Cain.